0
article(s)
Voir le panier
Vous n'avez aucun article dans votre panier.
Choosing between Cabernet Sauvignon and Syrah/Shiraz often comes down to what you value most in red wine: Cabernet’s graphite-lined structure and classic cassis, or Shiraz’s spice-driven generosity and plush fruit. To give you a true apples-to-apples comparison, we line up two cool-climate expressions from the same producer and region, so you can isolate varietal character from winemaking and terroir variables. If you’re building a smart, versatile collection—or simply deciding what to pour with dinner—this guide helps you weigh the trade-offs in style, ageability, and value.
Both wines featured in this comparison are available through Bidvino's authenticated collection with verified provenance and Hong Kong storage.
Table of Contents
Quick Comparison Table
| Feature | Stella Bella Cabernet Sauvignon 2022 | Stella Bella Shiraz 2021 |
|---|---|---|
| Price (HKD) | $210 | $230 |
| Vintage | 2022 | 2021 |
| Region | Margaret River, Australia | Margaret River, Australia |
| Grape Variety | Cabernet Sauvignon (with 9% Malbec) | Shiraz (Syrah) |
| Critic Score | NR | NR |
| Drinking Window | 2024–2032 | 2024–2029 |
| Best For | Structure-led reds; cellaring; classic pairings | Spice-friendly cuisine; versatile entertaining |
Note: Prices are approximate in HKD. Verify current pricing with Bidvino.
Stella Bella Cabernet Sauvignon 2022 (Margaret River)
Producer: Stella Bella
Region: Margaret River, Australia
Vintage: 2022 – warm, dry, clean fruit, expressive tannins
Grape Variety: Cabernet Sauvignon (with 9% Malbec)
Alcohol: 14.2%
Critic Score: NR
Price: $210 HKD
Drinking Window: 2024–2032
Available at: Our vintages change seasonally. Check what is in stock here: Bidvino
Producer Background
Stella Bella is one of Margaret River’s benchmark boutique producers, founded in 1996 and led by winemaker Luke Jolliffe. The estate champions sustainable viticulture and a site-led approach that focuses on clarity of fruit and refined structure rather than overt power. Cabernet Sauvignon is a regional calling card; the house style emphasizes fresh acidity, fine tannins, and a quietly confident use of French oak to frame varietal detail. Across the range, Stella Bella’s wines are known for poise and purity, making them reliable references for collectors seeking classic, cool-climate expressions at fair prices.
Vintage Analysis
Margaret River 2022 was warm and largely dry, delivering healthy, clean fruit and excellent flavor concentration. Cabernet benefited from even ripening and low disease pressure, producing ripe but focused tannins and vibrant red-to-black fruit. Compared with cooler seasons, 2022 wines tend to show a little more mid-palate flesh without losing the region’s hallmark line of acidity. Expect immediate appeal and a comfortable cellaring arc of 6–8+ years for well-made examples.
Tasting Notes
Visual: Vibrant ruby with a youthful purple rim.
Nose: Raspberry, cranberry, and fresh plum with violet and graphite; a whisper of vanillin from French oak.
Palate: Medium-bodied, bright redcurrant and cranberry at the core; hints of satsuma plum; precise acidity and ripe, fine-grained tannins carry the line.
Finish: Focused, clean, and sapid with a refreshing, salivating close.
Key Strengths
- Classically structured Cabernet with lift and definition at an accessible price.
- Ripe yet fine tannins suitable for cellaring or decant-and-pour service.
- Food-friendly acidity that excels with grilled meats and hard cheeses.
Considerations
- No major critic scores published; you’re buying on producer track record and style.
- Less opulent than warmer-climate Cabernets; lovers of plush Napa style may find it lean.
Stored in Bidvino's temperature-controlled facility.
Stella Bella Shiraz 2021 (Margaret River)
Producer: Stella Bella
Region: Margaret River, Australia
Vintage: 2021 – cooler, long ripening, aromatic clarity
Grape Variety: Shiraz (Syrah)
Alcohol: 14.1%
Critic Score: NR
Price: $230 HKD
Drinking Window: 2024–2029
Available at: Our vintages change seasonally. Check what is in stock here: Bidvino
Producer Background
Working from multiple sub-regional sites across Margaret River, Stella Bella crafts cool-climate Shiraz that leans into perfume, spice, and savory detail rather than sheer weight. Whole-bunch components are used judiciously to lift aromatics and add a sappy, spicy dimension. French oak plays a supporting role, keeping fruit purity front and center. The goal is a medium-bodied style that reads closer to Syrah in the Northern Rhône idiom than to the warmer Barossa/Shiraz stereotype—ideal for collectors who value nuance and food compatibility.
Vintage Analysis
The 2021 season in Margaret River was cooler with a long ripening window, encouraging excellent flavor development at modest alcohols. For Shiraz, that translated into vivid aromatics—plum, anise, clove—and beautifully shaped tannins. Whole-bunch ferments found an especially comfortable home in 2021, adding lift and spice while preserving tension. The wines are poised and savory, typically drinking well on release yet showing enough structure for short- to mid-term cellaring.
Tasting Notes
Visual: Dark red core with purple hues, moderate density.
Nose: Plum, star anise, clove; lifted whole-bunch freshness; subtle earth and savory undertones.
Palate: Medium-bodied and juicy; blackcurrant, star anise, and black spice; silky texture and delicate earthiness.
Finish: Supple and balanced with gentle spice echo and fine, silky tannins.
Key Strengths
- Aromatic lift and spice from whole-bunch ferments enhance complexity.
- Versatile with a broad range of cuisines, including spice-driven dishes.
- Moderate structure makes it approachable without extended decanting.
Considerations
- Less weight than Barossa-style Shiraz; those seeking power may want a riper region.
- Cellaring horizon is shorter than the Cabernet’s in most cellars.
Stored in Bidvino's temperature-controlled facility.
Head-to-Head Comparison
Vintage Quality Comparison
We’re comparing two strong seasons that express cool-climate Margaret River differently. The 2021 vintage delivered a cooler, long season. Shiraz benefited via heightened perfume, peppery spice, and fine-boned tannins—traits that align with “Syrah” character. The 2022 season was warmer and dry, yielding clean fruit with slightly riper phenolics. Cabernet shows that ripeness as a little more mid-palate flesh, without sacrificing line and freshness. Both wines are well made; your preference hinges on whether you value the lifted, savory tension of 2021 (Shiraz) or the riper, classical drive of 2022 (Cabernet).
Edge: Stella Bella Shiraz 2021 – for cool-season aromatic precision and poise.
Tasting Profile Comparison
This is where the varietal difference speaks loudly. Cabernet Sauvignon 2022 leads with redcurrant/cranberry, violet, graphite, and a seam of vanillin framing ripe, fine-grained tannins. It’s linear and architectural, finishing clean and refreshing. The Shiraz 2021 is more outwardly charming: plum and blackcurrant meet star anise, clove, and a subtle whole-bunch sap that brings lift. Texture is silkier, with gentle earthiness and spice carrying the finish. If you enjoy structure and classicism, Cabernet has the edge. If you prefer generosity, spice, and immediate charm, Shiraz wins.
Edge: Preference-driven – Cabernet for structure and graphite; Shiraz for spice and silk.
Aging Potential
At this price level and style, neither wine is intended for decades of aging, but Cabernet generally stretches further. The 2022 Cabernet’s tannin profile and acidity suggest a comfortable 6–8+ years, developing subtle leaf, cedar, and tobacco while retaining core fruit. Shiraz 2021 should drink beautifully over the next 3–5 years, gaining savory notes but prioritizing freshness and perfume over long-term tertiary complexity. Decanting both for 30–60 minutes will help today; the Cabernet benefits more from air.
Edge: Stella Bella Cabernet Sauvignon 2022 – superior tannic backbone and longer runway.
Value Retention & Investment
These are high-quality, accessibly priced estate wines designed for drinking, not speculation. Historically, Margaret River Cabernet as a category enjoys broader international recognition than Margaret River Shiraz, which can translate to slightly better secondary-market interest. Still, at $210–$230 HKD, value is primarily realized in the glass. For collection strategy, Cabernet offers a marginal edge for short-term vertical building (e.g., future 2023–2025 releases) if you enjoy tracking vintages.
Edge: Stella Bella Cabernet Sauvignon 2022 – category recognition favors Cabernet for modest value retention.
Food Pairing Versatility
Cabernet’s acidity and tannins love protein and fat: ribeye, lamb chops, aged cheddar, and rosemary roast potatoes. Shiraz’s spice and silkier texture shine with Cantonese roast duck, char siu, Xinjiang lamb skewers, five-spice pork belly, or pepper-crusted tuna. In mixed menus and family-style dining—common in Hong Kong—Shiraz’s lower tannin impact often integrates more seamlessly across diverse dishes.
Edge: Stella Bella Shiraz 2021 – broader range with spice-forward and multi-dish meals.
Price-to-Quality Ratio
Both wines overdeliver for their price, offering genuine cool-climate character and thoughtful winemaking. The Cabernet 2022 provides classical structure, definition, and cellar-friendly balance at $210 HKD—a compelling entry to serious Margaret River Cabernet. The Shiraz 2021’s whole-bunch perfume and savory complexity at $230 HKD is equally impressive, but the Cabernet’s additional aging headroom nudges it ahead on pure QPR for collectors who cellar.
Edge: Stella Bella Cabernet Sauvignon 2022 – structure plus cellarability at a slightly lower price.
Which Wine Should You Choose?
Best for Immediate Drinking
Winner: Stella Bella Shiraz 2021
The silkier tannins, lifted aromatics, and whole-bunch spice make the Shiraz ready to pour with minimal decanting. It’s a relaxed dinner-party achiever, especially with Cantonese and Southeast Asian dishes where gentle tannin and savory spice integrate gracefully.
Best for Cellaring & Investment
Winner: Stella Bella Cabernet Sauvignon 2022
Cabernet’s finer-grained tannins and fresh acidity translate into a longer drinking arc and slightly better category recognition. Expect it to evolve nicely over 6–8+ years, developing cedar and tobacco while keeping bright red fruit.
Best Value for Money
Winner: Stella Bella Cabernet Sauvignon 2022
At $210 HKD, the classic structure, clarity of fruit, and aging flexibility offer exceptional value—especially if you plan to track the next few vintages to build a mini vertical in your cellar.
Best for Special Occasions
Winner: Stella Bella Shiraz 2021
The Shiraz brings immediate fragrance and crowd-pleasing charm. Its spice-driven profile is engaging in a social setting and pairs effortlessly with shared plates and roast meats without dominating the table.
Best for First-Time Collectors
Winner: Stella Bella Shiraz 2021
Approachable structure, vivid aromatics, and broad food compatibility make it a stress-free cellar starter. You’ll learn how cool-climate Shiraz evolves over five years without committing to long-term cellaring timelines.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which wine is better for investment?
At these price points, both are drinker’s wines. If you’re seeking modest value retention, the Cabernet Sauvignon 2022 has a slight advantage thanks to the broader market recognition of Margaret River Cabernet. Still, your best “return” here is drinking quality rather than speculation.
Which has better aging potential?
Cabernet Sauvignon 2022. Its fine-grained tannins and acidity support a 6–8+ year window. The Shiraz 2021 is at its best 3–5 years from vintage, emphasizing perfume and spice rather than tertiary development.
What are the key differences in taste?
Cabernet shows redcurrant, cranberry, violet, and graphite with a linear, refreshing finish. Shiraz leans into plum, blackcurrant, star anise, and clove with a silkier texture and savory lift from whole-bunch fermentation. One is more architectural; the other more expressive and spicy.
Which pairs better with food?
For steak, lamb, and aged cheeses, choose Cabernet 2022. For multi-dish family meals, Cantonese roast meats, five-spice pork, or peppered tuna, the Shiraz 2021 integrates more easily and adds aromatic complexity.
How do the prices compare?
They are tightly aligned: Cabernet 2022 at approximately $210 HKD, Shiraz 2021 at approximately $230 HKD. Both offer strong value; the Cabernet’s additional cellaring capacity slightly improves its price-to-quality proposition for collectors.
Should I buy both or choose one?
If your cellar can accommodate both, the pair offers a “varietal study” from the same producer and region—ideal for learning Cabernet vs Syrah/Shiraz side by side. If you must choose one: Cabernet for structure/aging; Shiraz for immediate versatility.
Are these representative of Syrah/Shiraz and Cabernet styles?
Yes, in a cool-climate Australian context. Cabernet here is precise and graphite-tinged, while Shiraz reads as Syrah-like—spiced, savory, and medium-bodied. For riper stylistic benchmarks, look to Barossa (Shiraz) or warmer New World Cabernets.
Where can I buy these wines in Hong Kong?
Both are available via Bidvino’s Hong Kong platform with provenance verification and local storage. See the product links in each profile for current availability and pricing.
Final Verdict: Which Wine Wins?
Cabernet Sauvignon vs Syrah/Shiraz is a question of structure versus spice. Stella Bella’s Cabernet Sauvignon 2022 offers definition, freshness, and an aging runway that will reward patience. The Shiraz 2021 leans into perfume, whole-bunch lift, and silkier tannins for immediate, food-friendly enjoyment. Budget and price are near-equal, so the decision rests on taste preference and your timeline. If you want a modest cellaring project and classic Cabernet traits, choose the 2022 Cabernet. If you prioritize versatility and aromatic charm for dinner this week, choose the 2021 Shiraz. Serious collectors may reasonably buy both for a controlled, cool-climate varietal comparison in the cellar.
Explore both wines at Bidvino with transparent HKD pricing, authentication guarantee, and expert guidance for Hong Kong collectors.
Sources & References
This comparison is based on vintage analysis, critic scores (Wine Advocate, Jancis Robinson, James Suckling), producer technical sheets, auction data (Sotheby's, Christie's), and tasting analysis. Both wines verified through Bidvino's provenance standards.
Last Updated: January 2026
Bidvino Customer Service
